Entertainment Earth
[TF.N Main] [Contact Us]
[Books - Main]
[Books -  More]
[Star Wars Book Reviews]

[Star Wars Book Release Schedule]

[Foreign Covers]

[EU Roundtable]

Latest Releases...
[Lost Tribe of the Sith: Secrets]

Lost Tribe of the Sith: Secrets [EB]

[Episode I: The Phantom Menace]

Episode I: The Phantom Menace [PB]

[Millennium Falcon Owner's Workshop Manual]

Millennium Falcon Owner's Workshop Manual [HC]

[Darth Plagueis]

Darth Plagueis [HC]

[The Wrath of Darth Maul]

The Wrath of Darth Maul [YR]

[Shadow Hunter]

Darth Maul: Shadow Hunter [PB]

[Shadow Games]

Shadow Games [PB]

[The Old Republic: Revan]

The Old Republic: Revan [HC]


Riptide [PB]

[The Complete Vader]

The Complete Vader [HC]

[Star Wars Art: Comics]

Star Wars Art: Comics [HC]

[Heir to the Empire]

Heir to the Empire: The 20th Anniversary Edition [HC]

[Fate of the Jedi: Ascension]

Fate of the Jedi: Ascension [HC]

[Popular Stories]
CEII: Jabba's Palace Reunion - Massive Guest Announcements

Star Wars Night With The Tampa Bay Storm Reminder

Stephen Hayford Star Wars Weekends Exclusive Art

ForceCast #251: To Spoil or Not to Spoil

New Timothy Zahn Audio Books Coming

Star Wars Celebration VII In Orlando?

May The FETT Be With You

Mimoco: New Mimobot Coming May 4th

[Jedi Council Forums]
Troy Denning's Dark Nest trilogy (spoilers allowed)

The Official Alpha, the ARC Troopers and the Commandos Thread

The EU and Episode III: Revenge of the Sith- Spoilers Allowed

Secrets of the Jedi

Most powerful person in the galaxy

The Ages of EU Characters
There are no polls
currently operating
in this sector.
Please check
back soon.

View Poll Archives


Star Wars on Trial

Mike?s Rating

3.4 / 4


Debates on the authenticity of the Star Wars franchise and the hero-or-villain status of George Lucas are at the heart of these essays by bestselling science-fiction authors. The incredible popularity of the movies has led to the formation of strong emotions within the science fiction community on the strengths and flaws of the films, exemplified here by David Brin's attacks and Matthew Woodring Stover's defense of the movies. This intense examination of the epic works addresses a broad range of issues?from politics, religion, and the saga's overall logic to the impact of the series on bookshelf space as well as science-fiction film. The question Is George Lucas a hero for bringing science fiction to a mass audience or a villain who doesn't understand the genre he's working for? is discussed before a final "Judge's Verdict" on the greatness?or weakness?of the franchise is reached.


Mike: The average fan's first reaction to Star Wars on Trial, one could be forgiven for assuming, is to wonder less about the book's actual content than about the conclusions it draws. Guilty or not, anyone who spends time thinking about the questions the book poses is bound to wonder whether their own perspective receives some degree of validation from the authors involved. It was not my initial intent to reveal the book's conclusions in this review, because such knowledge would inevitably taint one's future enjoyment of the book for the unbiased debate it's meant to be.

It turns out, however, that the book offers no conclusions: the "Verdict" section is essentially an invitation for readers to visit a web page and discuss the matter further with some of the creative personnel involved as well as other fans. Not only is this kind of disappointing when viewing the book as a self-contained experience, it also seems to indicate that no conclusion will ever be drawn by anyone. The web page's discussion forums, whose location I won't divulge here, don't look to have been terribly active in the time following the book's initial release last June, and there isn't even any kind of poll to gauge the overall reaction of people who did find their way there.

What makes this acceptable, though, and what drives me to reveal this to you now, is that it wouldn't really matter what conclusion was reached, either by the pros or the fans. The book succeeds not because of its ability to sway anyone one way or another, but because of the conversation. It might've been better, in fact, to call it something like Star wars: Perspectives; what makes it worth the read, and the lack of a verdict, is the plethora of fascinating points of view presented on both sides of the aisle: Star Wars as fantasy, and as the hardest of sci-fi; as anime, as parable, as cultural pariah, and as comedy; as a big, shiny sports car in Karen Traviss' driveway (read the book).

And besides: as defense attorney Matthew Stover, I think, would agree, the debate's very existence ensures that Star Wars comes out on top. The value of the saga, and by extension, this book, is inchoate in the fact that so many intelligent, creative individuals can each have a wildly different interpretation of it, without a single one of them being wrong.

Entertainment Earth
[All Posters]
Star Wars - Episode III - Yoda - Stand Up
Search For Posters, Cardboard Stand-Ups & T-Shirts!
Upcoming Birthdays
(next 10 days)
6/6 - Daniel Logan
6/7 - Liam Neeson
[Rebelscum.com - Star Wars Collecting]
[TheForce.Net - FanFilms]
[TheForce.Net - FanForce] [TheForce.Net - Fan Art]
TheForce.Net - Your Daily Dose of Star Wars Entertainment Earth
The Galaxy is Listening
Entertainment Earth
[TF.N Main] [TF.N FAQ] [Contact Us]