There are no polls currently operating in this sector. Please check back soon. View Poll Archives
The People vs. George Lucas Press Posted By Mike on March 13, 2010
Entertainment Weekly has taken notice of the new fan created documentary, The People vs. George Lucas following its debut at the South by Southwest Film Festival in Austin, Texas. Click here for an interview with director Alexandre O. Philippe and if you're unaware of the new documentary, click through the related links below to catch up.
"Focusing on the symbiotic relationship between George Lucas and his fans the film chronicles a whole generation?s fascination with Star Wars, leading into the prequels and how those films caused a giant and negative reaction from the usually dependable and loyal fanbase.
Director Alexandre O. Philippe was able to get some impressive interviews with people like OT producer Gary Kurtz and the ever disgruntled man-in-the-suit David Prowse, but the focus is always on the fans, which is both the point and the failure of this documentary.
Failure might be too harsh of a word. It?s definitely a success at what it sets out to be, the definitive document on the arguments for and against the prequels, but the problem is that for anybody who is or was a Star Wars fan there is nothing new. It?s like listening to the discussions you?ve had with your friends ever since 1999 or even earlier? the real divide starts with the Special Editions.
There are other angles, with professors discussing Star Wars? true impact on culture and the gray area of the creator?s artistic rights vs. the audience?s right to the art. Those are fascinating topics, but are presented and quickly moved on from so they can get a bunch of fans talking about how stupid Jar-Jar Binks is.
I?ve had these discussions, you?ve had these discussions and I?m sad to say that I think this movie?s about 5 years too late. It almost feels like its trying to open up old wounds. Most of us that hate the prequels have made our peace and moved on. Those that love them are happy anyway."
UPDATE #2: Today we have a new article about the documentary from Reuters as well as a new review from Film School Rejects. (which is pretty blatant in its ani-Lucas bias)