Home Contact Forums Movies
Games Fandom
Home Contact About Forums Movies Television Literature Games Fandom Podcast
THEFORCE.NET THEFORCE.NET

TFN Review: The Star Wars #3 By J.W. Rinzler

Posted by Justin on November 6, 2013 at 07:49 PM CST

Synopsis: In the aftermath of Aquilae's attack on the Empire's Space Fortress, Jedi-Bendu General Luke Skywalker attempts to escape the conquered world with his apprentice Annikin Starkiller and Princess Leia. Meanwhile, construction droids See Threepio and Artwo Detwo, having escaped the Space Fortress during the battle, begin their own adventure on Aquilae.

There's a storytelling balance vital to telling a story truly worthy of the name Star Wars. This balance requires just the right amount of action, adventure, character, and plot. Too little of one and it falls flat. Too much of one and it feels forced.

Issue #3 of The Star Wars spends most of its time jumping back and forth between those extremes. While it's not necessarily bad, it never manages to strike the right balance between plot development and character building that's needed to drive the story forward in an engaging way.

With the battle against the Empire's Space Fortress ending in a resounding defeat for Aquilae and Imperial forces invading their world, the invigorating sense of urgency that so effectively carried the previous issue should have continued in this one. Instead, the central characters meander from one plot point to another in a methodical way that never quite succeeds at conveying that they realize how much more desperate their situation is becoming.

While my opinion of The Star Wars' third issue isn't the best, I'm still mindful that this is a single story being released in eight chapters. Just as every movie has slower moments of necessary exposition, every chapter of this story isn't going to be as enthralling as the attack on the Space Fortress. But that doesn't mean that the exposition has to feel as forced, or the characters as flat, as in this issue.

I really hope that the remaining chapters of The Star Wars that aren't built around a large action sequence can make better use of the unique opportunity this adaptation presents. Create separate but equally memorable versions of classic characters and make me care about them. Give me a reason to invest in their story and stay invested until the end. Aside from Kane Starkiller and Luke Skywalker, none of these characters transcend their statuses as rough draft versions of better characters.

The Star Wars works best when it embraces its own identity and sticks to telling its own story. It should stay away from shoehorning in direct lines and references from the films unless they organically fit into the context of the story. Doing so serves no purpose and appears to be there only to remind us that this is where Star Wars came from. Removing that kind of fan service and allowing the story to stand on its own would strengthen its integrity and justify it as a truly relevant addition the Star Wars pantheon.

My criticisms aside, I still believe The Star Wars is a worthwhile read. Once you're able to read the entire story in one sitting, it's very possible that what didn't work in this issue will no longer be a problem. Mike Mayhew's art continues to impress, and I have a lot of respect for J.W. Rinzler as a writer.

My only hope is that next month's issue overcomes the limitations I spoke of earlier to deliver the best version of The Star Wars possible.

Rating: 2 Out Of 5

Related Stories:

TFN Review: The Star Wars #0
TFN Interview: Dark Horse Comics' The Star Wars Artist Mike Mayhew
TFN Review: The Star Wars #4 by J.W. Rinzler
TFN Review: Star Wars Art: Concept by Lucasfilm Ltd. (Foreword by Joe Johnston)
TFN Review: Star Wars #2 by Dark Horse Comics

Entertainment Earth

Follow Us!

Star Wars Celebration 2019 Chicago

The ForceCast

The ForceCast is our popular Star Wars podcast that features news, commentary, interviews, and discussion about the Star Wars saga! Listen Now!

The Blue Moon Cantina XIX ~~ The Blue Moon Awakens


Diagon Alley: The Official Harry Potter Thread
Political ****posting Thread
The All-New, All-Different JCC Astronomy Thread

Rebelscum.com

Rebelscum.com provides the latest in collecting news. The site features up-to-the-minute news and images, coverage of Star Wars conventions, several product databases, countless reference galleries and archives, and more.Visit Now!

Birthdays
Upcoming Birthdays & Anniversaries in next 10 Days

7/23 - John Dicks
7/26 - Star Wars Celebration Europe II (2013)
7/27 - Donnie Yen

Entertainment Earth

Jedi Journals
Jedi Journals

Jedi Journals is the longest running Star Wars literature podcast in the galaxy. Listen Now!

Advertisment
Entertainment Earth

Entertainment Earth was started in a garage in 1995, and has since become the "go-to" source and experts for the latest and greatest action figures, bobble heads, toys, gifts, and collectibles! Visit Now!

The IndyCast
The Indy Cast

The IndyCast is the world's most popular Indiana Jones podcast! Ed Dolista and his team take a look at all the latest news, reviews and interviews! Listen Now!

2018 TFN, LLC.